Detention, and the hour you cannot bill for
A detained hour costs about $144. The market pays $40 to $75 for it. Here is the whole calculation, and how to price the wait before you accept the load.
Detention pay is not compensation. At the rates the market pays, it is a partial refund on a loss you have already taken, and the part it never refunds is the hours of service the wait consumed.
What detention actually costs
A truck sitting at a dock is losing money in three separate ways at once, and only one of them shows up on the invoice.
- Fixed cost keeps running. The truck payment, the insurance, the permits and the overhead accrue per day regardless of whether the wheels turn.
- Hours of service are consumed. The 14-hour on-duty window does not pause for a slow receiver. Every hour at the dock is an hour permanently removed from that day's driving capacity.
- The next load moves out of reach. A three-hour wait does not delay you three hours. It frequently delays you a full day, because the delivery appointment you could have made is now tomorrow's.
The clock you cannot bill for
This is the part that makes detention structurally worse than it looks.
The 14-hour window starts when the driver goes on duty and runs continuously until it expires. It does not stop for loading, for a dock queue, for lumper paperwork, or for anything except the qualifying sleeper-berth splits. Eleven of those fourteen hours may be spent driving; the other three are the entire budget for fuelling, inspections, scaling and every dock in the day.
| Hour of the 14 | Clean day | Day with 3h detention |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-trip, fuel | 0.75 h | 0.75 h |
| At shipper | 1.00 h | 4.00 h |
| Driving | 11.00 h | 8.25 h |
| Break (30 min) | 0.50 h | 0.50 h |
| At receiver, post-trip | 0.75 h | 0.50 h |
| Window used | 14.00 h | 14.00 h |
| Miles at 58 mph | 638 | 479 |
Three hours at a dock cost 159 miles of earning capacity on that day. At a $2.20 net contribution per mile, that is $350, and the detention cheque, if it arrives at all, will be $50 to $150.
The real cost of a detained hour
Work it from the truck's daily economics rather than from a per-hour rate, because the per-hour rate is the thing being disputed.
| Annual fixed cost of the truck | $50,900 |
| Operating days per year | 260 |
| Fixed cost per operating day | $195.77 |
| ÷ the 14-hour on-duty window (for reference: the lost contribution below already has to cover this, so it is not added again) | $13.98 per hour |
| Driver pay for the waiting hour (if paid) | $22.00 |
| Idle fuel, 0.8 gal/h at $6.28 | $5.02 |
| Direct cost of one detained hour (driver + idle fuel) | $27.02 |
| Lost contribution: 53 miles not driven × $2.20 | $116.60 |
| Full economic cost of one detained hour | $143.62 |
The direct cost is $27. That is the number a broker will argue about. The number that matters to your year is $144, and it is the one that never appears in a detention negotiation because the opportunity cost is invisible from the other side of the phone.
Which number to use, and when
Use the direct cost when you are deciding whether a specific wait was worth absorbing on a load you already committed to: the fixed cost is sunk either way.
Use the full economic cost when you are deciding whether to take a load from a facility with known dwell problems, or when setting a policy. That decision is made before the day is committed, so the lost capacity is real.
What detention typically pays
Common market terms, which are conventions rather than rules: every one of these is negotiable and every one of them is written into the rate confirmation or it does not exist:
| Term | Common range | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Free time before detention starts | 2 hours | Some shippers write 3 or 4. Push back: that is the whole giveaway |
| Detention rate | $40 – $75 / hour | Below the full economic cost in every case |
| Billing increment | 15 min – 1 hour | Hourly increments round in the shipper's favour |
| Cap | $300 – $600 / day | An uncapped clause is worth real money on a bad facility |
| Truck order not used | $150 – $350 | Frequently omitted. Always ask for it |
| Layover | $150 – $350 / night | Distinct from detention; both can apply |
Notice that the top of the detention range, $75 an hour, is is only about half the full economic cost of $144. Detention is not a profit centre and no clause will make it one. Its purpose is to make the shipper's dwell time expensive enough to fix.
Why detention is billed and not collected
Carriers routinely bill detention and routinely do not get paid for it. The reasons are almost always procedural, and all four are fixable before the truck ever arrives.
- No time stamps the shipper agreed to. A driver's word is not evidence. In-and out times must be signed on the bill of lading, or captured by a gate system, or documented by geofenced ELD data with the arrival and departure recorded.
- The clause was never in the confirmation. If detention terms are not written on the rate confirmation before dispatch, you are asking for a favour afterwards.
- It was billed late. Many contracts require accessorial claims within a fixed window, often 7 to 30 days. Bill it with the original invoice, not as an afterthought.
- The driver did not notify anyone in real time. Most terms require notice at the point free time expires. A call logged at hour 2 is worth several hundred dollars; the same call at hour 5 is worth nothing.
Four fields, most of the money
Arrival time, departure time, a signature, and the notification timestamp. If those four exist for every stop, detention collection stops being a negotiation and becomes an invoice. If any one is missing, it is a negotiation you will usually lose.
The accessorials most carriers leave on the table
Detention is the famous one. These are the ones that go unbilled:
| Accessorial | Typical | When it applies |
|---|---|---|
| Extra stop-off | $50 – $150 each | Every stop beyond the first pick and last drop |
| Driver assist / hand unload | $100 – $250 | Anything beyond dropping the trailer |
| Lumper fee | at cost + admin | Reimbursable; get the receipt at the dock |
| Tarping | $50 – $150 | Flatbed; varies with load height |
| Reconsignment / diversion | $100 – $300 + miles | Destination changed after dispatch |
| Redelivery | $150 – $400 | Receiver refused or closed on arrival |
| Trailer detention / per diem | $25 – $75 / day | Your trailer held beyond the agreed window |
| Team service | premium on line haul | Priced into the rate, not billed separately |
| Hazmat | $100 – $300 | Placarded freight |
| Weekend / after-hours delivery | $100 – $250 | Outside the receiver's standard window |
Two stop-offs, one driver assist and a tarp on a single load is $300 to $700. On a fleet running forty loads a week, systematically not billing half of them is a six-figure annual number.
Scoring a load with detention risk
The right way to handle a facility with a bad reputation is not to refuse it. It is to price the expected wait into the load before accepting.
expected_detention_cost = p(delay) × hours × full_hourly_cost
adjusted_net = normal_net − expected_detention_cost + expected_detention_pay
A facility that detains you three hours on 60% of visits, at $144 an hour full cost and $50 an hour paid after two hours free:
| Expected cost | 0.60 × 3 × $144 = −$259.20 |
| Expected pay | 0.60 × 1 × $50 = +$30.00 |
| Net adjustment to the load | −$229.20 |
That load needs $229 more than an identical load from a facility that loads in an hour. Not a refusal: a price. The calculator on this site has a detention and idle field for exactly this: put your expected wait in before you accept, not your actual wait afterwards.
A detention policy that works
- Terms on every confirmation. Free time, hourly rate, increment, cap, TONU and layover: before dispatch, in writing, no exceptions for a good broker.
- Driver notifies at free-time expiry. Set it as a hard rule with a timestamped message, not a phone call nobody logged.
- Signed in and out times on every BOL. If the facility will not sign, the driver photographs the gate log or the dock clock with the phone's timestamp on.
- Bill accessorials with the original invoice. Never separately, never later.
- Track dwell by facility, not by broker. The broker did not make you wait; the receiver did. After twenty visits you will know which four facilities cost you a day a month, and those are the ones to reprice or drop.
That last point is the one with compounding value. A carrier who can say "your Columbus DC averages 3.4 hours against a 2-hour free window across our last eleven visits, here are the timestamps" is not complaining. They are negotiating, and they usually win.
Price the wait before you accept
The load calculator has a detention and idle input. Enter the wait you expect at that facility and watch the verdict change before you commit the truck.
Want someone to review the numbers with you?
The calculators give you an estimate. A $49 Load Check goes further and reviews the actual numbers for your load, using your own operating costs.
Sources
- Detention, layover, TONU and accessorial ranges are common commercial conventions in North American truckload freight. They are negotiated terms, not published rates: treat them as a starting point for your own confirmations.
- Hours-of-service arithmetic follows the FMCSA 11-hour driving limit, 14-hour on-duty window and 30-minute break rule. See the hours-of-service guide.
- The cost tables use the same illustrative single-truck cost base as the rest of this site: $50,900 annual fixed, 260 operating days, $6.28 diesel (U.S. average, October 2026), $2.20 net contribution per mile. Substitute your own figures: the method is the point, not the numbers.
Related guides: Accessorials, the charges you keep forgetting to bill